• What We Do
    • Wealth Counseling
    • Investment Advisory Services
  • Who We Are
    • Our Team
    • Research Roundtable
  • How We Invest
    • Our Fiduciary Pledge
    • Investment Approach
    • Questions To Consider
    • Our Transparent Approach
  • Insights and Research

Insights and Research

Home  »  Managing The Market • Performance Measurement • Simplicity   »   Once Famous?

Once Famous?

By Charlie Henneman, CFA, July 3, 2021

Quarter end is upon us again, which means that fund lists will be published touting the latest investment category winners.

These lists will create headlines and often inspire special sections in journals.

Do they add value to investor portfolios, however, and generally result in positive outcomes for those who are attracted to the lists of recent winners?

One of the most consistent places to look for an answer comes along each year from S&P Global in the form of their Persistence Scorecards.  They keep tabs on whether or not top managers persist in staying at the top.

What does the data consistently say?

Having a little fun with an old saying, the higher a manager flies on a list, the more they seem to fall.

The eye-popping result this time…

“Of the top-half funds of 2016, 21.4% repeated that accomplishment in 2017, with just 4.8% ranking in the top half each year through 2020.”

These might seem to be astonishing results, but unfortunately not.

We pulled this quote from a previous S&P Persistence Scorecard, for a piece we published in 2017:

“No large-cap, mid-cap, or small-cap funds managed to remain in the top quartile at the end of the five-year measurement period.”

This incredible lack of performance persistence – by the smart, well-credentialed, well-resourced, and hard-working people managing these funds – does not exactly support the “outperformance is a result of skill” argument.

If anything, it suggests that more success is attributable to luck than we give it credit for.

As I did in a past life for the CFA Institute, I can imagine putting together conference panels to chew this over.  In doing so, I might ask this question:

If allocations to active managers are essentially low probability bets, are they deployed appropriately?

In my view, this is particularly interesting for fiduciaries.

If winning in investing is making fewer mistakes, then it’s all about probabilities. The data suggests that active management is, essentially, a low probability bet with a big ante. It can be fun and exciting, often featuring interesting and compelling, alpha personalities, but it has a cost, and data suggests the chance of experiencing multiple years of outperformance or investment alpha is random at best.

For fiduciaries, what is an appropriate allocation to a strategy with this profile?

We consistently ask these questions ourselves and wrote this when asked to comment on it for a trustee publication, Trust & Estates.

“Paraphrasing the wisdom of Berkshire Hathaway’s Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger and the origins of the word prudent, I would argue this – A fiduciary should stay focused on a judicious and rational review of the evidence to avoid big mistakes and wisely remember that excitement can be an enemy of what’s most suitable and profitable.”

I think the key word there is “evidence” and, according to S&P’s most recent Persistence Scorecard review, this is what it shows:

“98.5% chance that a top-quartile fund will not stay in the top quartile for the next four years.”

The whole story brings to mind a Howard Marks line…

“Our industry is full of people famous for being right once in a row.”

Back to where we started, quarter end top fund publications can make some investment managers famous.  Before following these lists and buying these funds, just beware.

Famous funds may only end up being famous once.


Related Reading:

Are Selectors Good At Selecting?

Outperformance in Down Markets 100% of the Time?

Prudently Passive?

The Simple Alternative

What Needs to Change?

S&P Global U.S. Persistence Scorecard Year-End 2020

Charlie Henneman, CFA
Website | + posts
  • Charlie Henneman, CFA
    https://fwpwealth.com/author/charlie/
    The Simple Alternative
  • Charlie Henneman, CFA
    https://fwpwealth.com/author/charlie/
    Is Smart Beta Smart?
  • Charlie Henneman, CFA
    https://fwpwealth.com/author/charlie/
    Waving Banners - Have Some ESG Managers Lost Their Way?
  • Charlie Henneman, CFA
    https://fwpwealth.com/author/charlie/
    Perspectives of a Trillion Dollar Investor - Our Conversation with Richard Ennis
SHARE
Tags:
Active Management, Index funds, Investing
RELATED ARTICLES
Staying Disciplined and Avoiding Unforced Errors
The track records of many successful professionals can be attributed to keeping it simple and avoiding unforced errors
Still Keeping A Steady Hand
Every year over the past 10 years we have written a similar letter.
Recessions – What Should Investors Do?
The evidence may surprise you.
All articles

Follow us on social media

Search Our Ideas

Subscribe to Our Posts


Important disclosures

Most Popular

  • The Simple Alternative – Keeps On Winning
  • The Simple Alternative
  • Say It Ain’t So, Joe
  • Are We Baking Portfolios with Bad Ingredients?
  • Crucial Elements in Wealth Management: Simplicity and Transparency

Browse by Theme

  • Fees
  • Fiduciary Duty
  • Investment Philosophy
  • Managing The Market
  • Peace of Mind
  • Performance Measurement
  • Private Investing
  • Quarterly Letter
  • Simplicity
  • Taxes
  • Transparency
  • Uncategorized
  • Values

FWP Logo Dark

Fiduciary Wealth Partners is a 100% employee owned firm that serves clients in a transparent, fiduciary manner.

We do not have any fee sharing arrangements with managers and do not have any broker-dealer conflicts. In addition, you will never see an arbitration clause in our contracts.

Everything we do is focused on assisting trustees, institutions and families with investment consulting, management and overall asset planning strategies.

  • Disclosures
  • ADV
  • Privacy Policy
  • Form CRS

Useful Links

  • Investment Advisory Services
  • Wealth Counseling
  • Our Team
  • Research Roundtable
  • Our Values
  • Questions To Consider
  • Insights and Ideas
  • Contact Us

Contact us

Phone

(617) 602-1900

Email

info@fwpwealth.com

Address

177 Huntington Avenue
20th Floor
Boston, MA 02115

 

View larger map

© 2020 FWP. All Rights Reserved. Fiduciary Wealth Partners Is An SEC Registered Investment Adviser.